Press "Enter" to skip to content

ECR survey results Q2 2020: Covid-19 crisis increases the economic and political risks for US, Japan, Europe and EMs

The shock ensuing from the lockdown measures taken to cease the unfold of coronavirus is as soon as once more dominating the world danger image, inflicting analysts to downgrade key economic elements in second quarter of 2020 and reassess the fiscal implications of the extraordinary state assist offered along side liquidity injections from central banks.

Two elements particularly are affected: the economic outlook-GNP variable, which is downgraded in 127 of the 174 nations since the earlier survey was undertaken in Q1 2020, and the employment/unemployment indicator, marked down in 118.

In complete 79 nations have seen their complete danger scores downgraded since Q1, with sharp falls occurring as soon as once more for Argentina and Lebanon, reflecting their ongoing debt-servicing issues, in addition to Iran, Iraq, Libya, Syria, and Yemen, which had been all high-risk choices to start with.

Czech Republic, Mexico and Sri Lanka are additionally notable amongst nations with greater danger profiles, together with an awesome many sovereign debtors throughout sub-Saharan Africa with commodity exposures, tightened entry to finance, home political issues and a rising tide of overseas debt.

The United States continues to descend into populist turmoil with Donald Trump, seemingly conscious of his declining recognition, concentrating on his base by way of xenophobic appeals each overseas and home

– Dan Graeber, GERM Report

It has been a torrid time too for rising and frontier markets, with elevated danger now going through buyers in Brazil, Chile, India, Indonesia, Nigeria and Peru, though not in Russia, Cambodia or Vietnam, that are all rising in the survey.

Among the 81 nations displaying improved security are a preponderance of island nations which can be clearly capable of provide higher safety towards coronavirus, particularly Bermuda, Dominican Republic, Fiji, Haiti, Jamaica, the Maldives and, impressively, Taiwan.

Also safer are Greece, Kazakhstan, Montenegro, Morocco and Paraguay in keeping with the survey’s multifactor metrics. Switzerland, in the meantime, stays the most secure nation worldwide, forward of Singapore and the Nordic nations, which all possess comparatively stronger macro-fiscal fundamentals, extra steady currencies, low corruption and different benefits.

Euromoney’s distinctive ‘crowd-sourcing’ danger survey is a responsive information to altering perceptions of taking part analysts in each the monetary and non-financial sectors, specializing in a variety of key economic, political, and structural elements affecting investor returns.

The survey is carried out quarterly amongst a number of hundred economists and different consultants, with the results compiled and aggregated, together with a measure of capital entry and sovereign debt statistics, to supply complete danger scores and rankings.


US downgraded

Normally low-risk superior industrialized nations have been despatched reeling by the coronavirus shock, though in the US there are additionally political connotations with the presidential elections in November quick approaching.

“The United States continues to descend into populist turmoil with Donald Trump, seemingly aware of his declining popularity, targeting his base through xenophobic appeals both foreign and domestic,” says survey contributor Dan Graeber, geopolitical analyst and founding father of the GERM Report.

“There stays a rising disconnect, in the meantime, between the economic system, as introduced in information headlines, and the economic system as introduced on the floor.

“US hiring, in keeping with the newest federal report, confirmed an uptick, prompting a wave of exuberance from the president’s Twitter feed. The information factors, nevertheless, ended earlier than the dramatic rise in coronavirus instances in the US south.

“The Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta revised its forecast for GDP upward on the latest jobs data, though its estimate for a 35.2% contraction in the second quarter is nothing to celebrate and economists are worried about what happens when federal stimulus runs out at the end of July.”

This concern is borne out in the survey with the US danger rating dropping even additional in Q2 2020 to increase a longer-term declining pattern.


US economic danger has elevated primarily attributable to a downwardly revised rating for the employment/unemployment indicator, in addition to the truth that each one six political danger indicators are decrease. This means the US is down 4 locations in the world danger rankings to this point this 12 months, at 21st, placing the nation between Iceland and Israel by way of comparative danger metrics.

Canada has additionally succumbed to downgrades in Q2 2020. The nation is “flattening the curve” so far as coronavirus is anxious, says Graber about Canada, however its economic system continues to face downward strain.

“Relying partly on the huge oil reserves in Alberta, a lingering low value for crude oil means corporations have little income left over for drilling. Fitch Ratings at the finish of June stated the coronavirus pandemic, coupled with low world oil demand, elevated the probability for a extreme recession in 2020.

“Canada’s GDP is expected to contract by 7.1% this year and growth prospects further out are limited.”

Japan and Europe in the doldrums

Japan has fallen 5 locations in the danger rankings to 39th and is now pitched between the UAE and Spain. There are downgrades to key economic indicators reflecting a raft of poor output, gross sales and confidence readings, the postponement of the Tokyo Olympics and rising unemployment.

Political elements together with institutional danger, the regulatory and policymaking setting and authorities stability are additionally revised decrease, with the nation embroiled in deteriorating diplomatic and commerce relations with South Korea and the governing social gathering beset by low approval scores following a collection of scandals.

Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Sweden have all succumbed to an additional rise in investor danger as their economies are weakened and fiscal pressures intensify attributable to the Covid-19 crisis.

The OECD is predicting steep falls in GDP and sharply raised unemployment charges this 12 months for all G10 members, with France, Italy and the UK worst affected. The UK’s danger rating has stabilized in the survey, buoyed partly by political stability, however it’s nonetheless down considerably this 12 months, with the prospect of failing to achieve an settlement for a Brexit commerce deal a further danger issue.

Internationally, Beijing’s credibility has hit a brand new low given widespread criticism to its response to the preliminary outbreak of Covid-19 and the ongoing backlash towards some features of the Belt and Road Initiative

– Daniel Wagner, Country Risk Solutions

Independent sovereign danger skilled Norbert Gaillard believes extra in a W-shaped than a V or U-shaped restoration for the world economic system, noting that after the economic shock: “There is the elevated danger of a monetary shock, regardless of the proactive insurance policies applied by central banks, pushed by a surge in non-performing loans in rising nations and probably in the US if coronavirus instances nonetheless go up in July.

“Such a monetary crisis would unfold to European banks and depress ECR scores once more.”

Gaillard goes on to state that the Covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated inequality inside and between European nations, which may have numerous penalties.

“A country like Spain will be especially affected. Given the structurally high level of the unemployment rate there, I do not expect the general government fiscal balance to return to its 2019 level (of -2.8% of GDP) in the next three years,” he says.

He additionally sees the casual economic system rising in most nations, particularly in southern Europe.

“This will undermine the capacity of governments to levy taxes efficiently. Accordingly, I have already downgraded the government finances, and regulatory and policy environment sub-ratings for the five top European economies. I have also downgraded the corruption sub-rating for several of them.”

In Germany, he says, the authorities is now satisfied that solidarity between EU members is required.

“We don’t know yet how such solidarity will materialize. The European Investment Bank and/or the European Stability Mechanism may play a key role. The creation of Eurobonds is another option. In any case, this new framework will support the ECR ratings of EU members in the medium term and make the euro more resilient than expected,” says Gaillard.

He additionally sees the Covid-19 crisis serving as a catalyst.

“The boastful behaviour of Chinese authorities has led the European Commission and some European governments (comparable to France and Germany) to aim to regain some type of sovereignty.

“Some multinational firms will relocate jobs in Europe, others could revise their partnerships with Chinese firms. Next, the EC seems determined to fight against foreign subsidies which skirt EU market rules. This new paradigm must be scrutinized carefully because it could contribute to ‘re-industrializing’ Europe and boost ECR ratings in the medium term as well as mark the end of the populist momentum.”

Two sides to China’s story

China, which has managed to fight the illness and reopen its economic system, has seen some enchancment on this newest survey, though its danger rating stays under the stage prevailing at the finish of final 12 months.

Effective quarantining and economic stimulus are supporting restoration prospects, with China one in every of the uncommon exceptions that will nonetheless see GDP develop in actual phrases this 12 months, albeit weakly, bolstered by bettering industrial sector prospects and home demand.

In response, forecasts for financial institution and foreign money stability, and authorities funds have begun to enhance.

Survey contributor Friedrich Wu, a professor at Nanyang Technological University, acknowledges the enchancment to China’s economic outlook since April.

“Both the IMF and Asian Development Bank have revised upward China’s GDP outlook for 2020 to 1.0% to 1.5% growth, with May-June figures showing that manufacturing activity, retail/auto sales, and real estate transactions in China had all shot up, indicating a general recovery in private consumption,” he says.

Still, China’s rating is worse than final 12 months, weighed down by overseas coverage points referring to the state of affairs in Hong Kong and worsening relations with the US and UK.

Daniel Wagner, chief government of Country Risk Solutions, is definitely pessimistic, believing the political and economic local weather will deteriorate in China for the foreseeable future.

“Politically, Beijing’s crackdown on free speech and internet freedom continues, with anyone who is vocal in their dissent against the Chinese Communist Party becoming a target for political persecution,” he says.

“Internationally, Beijing’s credibility has hit a brand new low given widespread criticism to its response to the preliminary outbreak of Covid-19 and the ongoing backlash towards some features of the Belt and Road Initiative.

“Economically, GDP growth had been projected to be just 2.5% for 2020, compared with 6.1% for 2019, the result of Covid-19 and a dramatic reduction in cross-border trade and investment. Even that now looks uncertain, with some analysts suggesting that GDP growth may even be negative for the year. Either way, it is likely to be the worst economic performance for half a century.”

Mixed image for EMs

Not all nations are seen as larger risks. Russia for occasion has proven additional enchancment, reflecting the truth the nation is relatively resilient to exterior shocks, with oil costs coming off their lows and with constitutional backing for Vladimir Putin’s reforms supporting authorities stability and the rouble.

By distinction nations which can be struggling to manage Covid-19, going through extra extreme economic shocks and with preliminary recoveries levelling off, have seen their danger scores worsen, placing their foreign money stability in danger.

ABN Amro economists collaborating in the survey consider that in the coming months rising market currencies will endure once more.

The restoration in economic information is generally factored in they argue in a recent research note. Investor sentiment will deteriorate and fundamentals seem weak for many nations, together with commodity costs and the US-China tensions.

Brazil is combating deep recession and the tax and administrative reforms required to handle its fiscal issues are delayed, threatening the Brazilian actual. In the newest survey Brazil has plummeted 14 locations in the world danger rankings and 24 locations total since the finish of final 12 months.

Indonesia is one other large faller, down 13 locations in the second quarter and a whopping 28 total, highlighting comparable uncertainty for the rupiah. Other large fallers embrace Mexico, India and a big swathe of sub-Saharan Africa’s indebted sovereigns reeling from the commodity shock and constrained entry to financing.


Africa on the brink

Although South Africa’s multi-year downgrades have now stabilized, different bond issuers on the continent have gotten riskier. These embrace Ethiopia, Kenya, Namibia and Tanzania, in addition to oil producers Cameroon, Gabon and Nigeria, as economies wrestle for commerce, tourism and funding in the aftermath of the pandemic.

Independent economist Jawhara Kanu says Ethiopia’s danger efficiency measures may appear sturdy due to continued main investments by the authorities, good administration of the Covid-19 outbreak, the indisputable fact that susceptible industries comparable to Ethiopian airways have been saved afloat and the nation’s rising significance as a regional participant. However, a deeper have a look at the nation’s political economic system reveals an underlying fragility.

“One layer to this fragility is the endless racial fractions between the different ethnicities and also between the state’s forces and protesters across the country. This translated in the recent security crackdown which caused the death of at least 235 people and a total internet blackout across the country,” says Kanu.

“Another layer is the dispute with Egypt over the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam that not only gives room for increased lobbying and external meddling in the country’s internal issues, but it also allows the government room to enlarge its authority under the cover of national security.”

In Nigeria, Rafiq Raji, chief economist with Macroafricaintel says the economic system may contract by wherever between 3% and 10% in 2020.

“A five-week lockdown to curtail the spread of the coronavirus stopped what was still a fragile recovery in its tracks. A recession is almost certain, with likely contractions in Q2 and Q3, though some sectors of the economy will recover faster than others,” he says.

“Banks are already beginning to restructure loans, as non-performing ones increase rapidly. As many firms were not able to do much business during the lockdown period and are still trying to put their affairs in order, many do not have the cash flow to service their loans.”

There are a myriad of challenges that persist comparable to the dramatic decline in oil costs, a frail regulatory setting and prevailing insecurity

– Crystal Byrd, USAID

Bank stability is definitely amongst the economic elements downgraded in the survey.

Raji additionally states that oil costs, though presently above the key $40 a barrel stage, will not be a trigger for optimism as a result of the authorities is pressured to cap manufacturing under its finances targets to adjust to OPEC cuts. Also, rising public debt is a trigger for concern with excessive debt servicing prices relative to income elevating alarm bells.

“With continued devaluation of the naira expected for the remainder of the year on likely lower hard currency inflows and eager foreign portfolio investors looking to exit their naira exposures, there is much to be cautious about in regard to Nigeria,” says Raji.

Crystal Byrd, an economist at USAID, provides that lately there was little enchancment to the public monetary administration techniques wanted to ship primary human providers in Nigeria, towards the backdrop of continued battle in northern Nigeria and a rising youth ‘bulge’ including to economic uncertainty.

“There are a myriad of challenges that persist such as the dramatic decline in oil prices, a frail regulatory environment and prevailing insecurity. With the additional layer of global pandemic one could predict that conditions would likely worsen in the short term.”

Nevertheless, she presents some hope for an African renaissance amongst Nigeria’s challenges, stating that the authorities is offering some economic aid to residents affected by the pandemic and that Nigeria is a vibrant and resilient nation, so the recession may very well be “deep but short”.

Indeed not all nations in the area have develop into riskier and there are different larger elements which can be probably to offer elements of the continent a elevate, as Diery Seck, director of the Center for Research on Political Economy, explains: “Significant changes have occurred in creating the west Africa common currency, which will help improve the soundness of monetary and banking policy. Regional integration in west Africa is getting stronger with better prospects of policy harmonization and more vibrant integration through the free trade zone.”

Winners and losers in Asia

Across Asia many nations are weathering the storm and have additionally been upgraded in the survey. These embrace Bangladesh, Cambodia, Taiwan and Vietnam, which have taken decisive motion to cease Covid-19 from spreading with out utilizing full lockdowns and have additionally benefited from funding as corporations relocate to keep away from commerce tariffs on China.

Still, there are a number of nations feeling the influence of downgrades to politico-economic elements, these embrace Indonesia, Malaysia, Sri Lanka, South Korea, Thailand, Hong Kong and Singapore.

Wagner of Country Risk Solutions says Singapore is very susceptible to world economic tendencies and has been hit exhausting this 12 months.

“The country’s ministry of trade and industry has projected negative GDP growth of between 0.7% and 4.0% this year. That said, the city state has an amazing ability to reinvent itself and stands to gain from a pending exodus of financial firms from Hong Kong. Singapore represents an attractive alternative.”

Nanyang’s Wu says authorities have dealt with the crisis competently however provides: “It is a regional trading, financial and travel hub. If Singapore reopens its borders too hastily, imported Covid-19 cases might surge and it would have to re-impose a lockdown again, and that would be a setback for the economy and its citizens.”

He can also be scathing of radical protesters in Hong Kong saying they’re “reaping what they sowed final 12 months.

“From an anti-extradition law movement, they crossed the ‘red line’ to advocate independence to challenge Beijing’s sovereignty rights,” he says.

“Many private businesses and peaceful residents in Hong Kong actually support China’s National Security Law imposed on it, because the law only targets a minority of radicals and will have little impact on normal, day-to-day operations of businesses and lives there.”

Whatever the deserves of the regulation, it has however elevated the risks of investing.

“The imposition of the National Security Law was no surprise given the passage of the law in 2015 by Beijing,” says Wagner.

That regulation emphasizes that “China must defend its national security interests everywhere” and “affects almost every domain of public life in China.” The regulation’s mandate covers politics, the navy, finance, faith, our on-line world, ideology and faith.

“The regulation has reworked Hong Kong’s political and economic panorama from being a spot the place concepts and free speech thrived to a spot the place individuals should now dwell and companies should perform in concern of claiming or doing one thing that could be interpreted as a risk to China’s nationwide safety.

“Many international businesses – especially in the financial services sector – may now choose to relocate to countries where that is not a consideration,” he warns.

CEE is break up

Central and jap Europe has fared significantly better than most areas with upgrades for Bosnia-Hercegovina, Estonia, Hungary, Montenegro and Slovenia occurring each in Q2 and throughout the first half of the 12 months total. However, it has additionally seen some important downgrades to Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Poland and Romania.

For Poland, Adam Antoniak, senior economist with Bank Pekao, notes the economic influence of the Covid-19 crisis and additionally a much less predictable political panorama enjoying out in the presidential elections.

“While at the beginning of current parliamentary campaign current president Andrzej Duda was leading the polls, and even had a chance to secure a second term in the first round of the election, in the face of general discontent linked to the pandemic his lead started diminishing over time,” he says.

“In the meantime the opposition Citizen Coalition changed presidential candidate Ewa Kidawa-Błońska with Rafał Trzaskowski, who managed to achieve stable recognition amongst voters in the first spherical.

“Now the outcome of the second round is a close call. For the ruling parliamentary majority cooperation with the opposition president could prove more cumbersome, so the political outlook has turned more uncertain.”

Several of Poland’s political danger indicators are downgraded to replicate this and in Czech Republic comparable downgrading has occurred in response to the ongoing fraud probe into prime minister Andrej Babis and the resultant anti-government protests.

Latam struggles with the virus

The outlook for the bigger economies in Latin America has been badly hit by the lockdowns required to comprise the virus. The influence of the world commerce shock on commodity costs has additionally affected many nations, together with copper producers Chile and Peru.

Chile’s political and social stability risks have been elevated by a collection of civil protests since October in response to the rising price of residing sparked by increases to Santiago’s metro fares, which highlighted the rising inequality in the nation.

With Chile now going through an economic crisis, the president below strain to attenuate the hardship it’s going to trigger and uncertainty surrounding the implications of a delayed constitutional referendum to be held later in the 12 months, many danger issue scores have deteriorated. These embrace authorities stability, institutional danger, and the regulatory and coverage setting, alongside GDP, employment and authorities funds.

Argentina can also be trying riskier as the authorities continues to combat an economic crisis on prime of the difficult debt restructuring, as are Mexico and Brazil.

Jessica Roldan, chief economist at Finamex notes the crisis arrived at the flawed time for Mexico with: “Major parts of GDP lowering or slowing down, amid deterioration of enterprise confidence and the lack of a cohesive message of key authorities individuals concerning the ‘rules of the game’ to conduct.

“Already in the midst of the crisis, a timid fiscal policy response focused only on those most vulnerable, left most firms and households alone to cope with the effects of lockdown and social distancing measures, thus increasing the likelihood of observing a slower recovery of employment and productive activities, which undermines the country’s ability to generate sustained growth.”

Roldan additionally notes the political dimension of the crisis shall be examined subsequent 12 months when intermediate and native elections will present how  the ruling Morena social gathering is faring.

In Brazil the place president Bolsonaro’s authoritarian tendencies, unstable cupboard and apathy in direction of Amazon rainforest destruction trigger concern, the risks have elevated considerably.

Raphael Lagnado, danger analyst at Velours International, says Brazil has been vastly affected by the lack of a coordinated response to the outbreak.

“Partisanship has marked policymaking, stoked a political crisis and hampered adherence to social distancing. Brazil’s institutional and macroeconomic foundations stay strong, however the following months will see steady deterioration in the authorities’s capability to behave successfully.

“Primary economic risks stem from dwindling GNP (from a forecasted -5.3% in April to -9.1% in June for 2020), sharp but controlled devaluation (R$4.84 against the dollar in mid-March to R$5.35 currently) and, in the medium term, inflation and liquidity issues owing to the extraordinarily low interest rate and possible use of fiscal easing to speed up recovery.”

MENA’s oil producers should adapt

The halving of oil costs is hitting the extra susceptible hydrocarbon exporters in the Middle East, depleting already weak income streams that worsen finances deficits and debt burdens. Algeria, Iran, Iraq, Libya and Kuwait are amongst the nations with deteriorating scores, with Syria, Yemen and Lebanon all going through crises.

The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) states are particularly susceptible notes Fadi Haddadin, economist at the Foreign Policy Association.

“The consequence of an over-reliance on vitality exports, lengthy understood to be a structural weak point of their economies, has develop into much more obvious and the state of affairs presents an particularly important problem to nations whose public funds are in a dire situation, comparable to Bahrain and Oman.

“The story of oil, together with the pandemic, will even influence labour markets. This may very well be a second for recalibration of reliance on overseas staff (particularly in the GCC), which may weaken a vibrant client base and in flip drastically shift requirements of residing.

“The oil value collapse will merely make the inevitable happen sooner, laying naked the indisputable fact that oil income dependency and huge public spending on salaries and social advantages have limits.

“It may also pose institutional/policy risks to the GCC (as a regional organization), in terms of regional economic integration and policy coordination. In other words, the GCC states may become more independent in both fiscal and monetary policymaking.”

It isn’t all gloom, nevertheless. Some nations have seen their scores enhance this quarter, together with Israel, Jordan, Egypt and not least Morocco, the standout nation with a powerful achieve.

Although the Moroccan economic system will nonetheless be hit by the Covid-19 pandemic, highlighted by an additional downgrading of the employment/unemployment indicator, the nation’s manufacturing is extraordinarily well-diversified and analysts are likely to count on the nation to emerge extra rapidly from the downturn than different north African debtors when tourism resumes.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *